K Grades

30 qualified kickers · single-component grade: Field Goal Over Expected per attempt — each kick compared to league baseline make rate for its distance, XPs folded in. Rewards risk-taking, penalizes easy misses (data 2016+) (see methodology)

QB RB WR TE OL CB S EDGE iDL LB K P

2025 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 2016

						FORMULA	CONTEXT
Rank
1	Justin Tucker	BAL	95.8	100	66	+0.124	97.4	100.0	100.0	57
2	Matt Bryant	ATL	82.8	97	94	+0.055	91.9	88.2	98.2	59
3	Adam Vinatieri	IND	82.4	93	75	+0.057	87.1	81.0	100.0	54
4	Chris Boswell	PIT	76.6	90	61	+0.044	84.0	78.6	100.0	49
5	Wil Lutz	NO	72.0	87	84	+0.031	82.4	73.3	98.0	57
6	Ryan Succop	TEN	70.6	83	65	+0.030	91.7	84.6	95.1	53
7	Dan Bailey	DAL	68.7	80	78	+0.025	84.4	66.7	100.0	56
8	Greg Zuerlein	LA	65.5	77	45	+0.023	86.4	62.5	100.0	54
9	Phil Dawson	SF	62.3	73	55	+0.015	85.7	72.7	97.1	53
10	Nick Folk	NYJ	59.8	70	57	+0.011	87.1	100.0	92.3	51
11	Brandon McManus	DEN	59.6	67	67	+0.010	85.3	66.7	97.0	55
12	Caleb Sturgis	PHI	59.2	63	72	+0.009	85.4	68.8	96.8	55
13	Matt Prater	DET	57.3	60	69	+0.006	86.1	81.0	93.9	58
14	Andrew Franks	MIA	55.1	57	63	+0.002	76.2	40.0	97.6	55
15	Mason Crosby	GB	50.1	53	77	-0.006	86.7	75.0	93.6	53
16	Jason Myers	JAX	49.7	50	66	-0.007	79.4	81.0	90.6	56
17	Sebastian Janikowski	LV	49.6	47	74	-0.007	82.9	68.4	94.9	56
18	Connor Barth	CHI	45.2	43	55	-0.015	78.3	57.1	96.9	54
19	Stephen Gostkowski	NE	44.8	40	81	-0.015	84.4	78.6	93.9	53
20	Cairo Santos	KC	41.7	37	74	-0.020	88.6	88.9	92.3	54
21	Cody Parkey	CLE	35.2	33	46	-0.034	80.0	61.5	95.2	51
22	Josh Lambo	LAC	32.1	30	78	-0.037	81.3	54.5	91.3	47
23	Nick Novak	HOU	31.4	27	66	-0.039	85.4	64.7	88.0	53
24	Chandler Catanzaro	ARI	30.1	23	75	-0.041	75.0	64.3	91.5	60
25	Graham Gano	CAR	30.0	20	72	-0.041	78.9	73.9	91.2	54
26	Dustin Hopkins	WAS	27.5	17	81	-0.046	81.0	62.5	92.3	53
27	Steven Hauschka	SEA	24.3	13	72	-0.053	89.2	90.0	82.9	53
28	Roberto Aguayo	TB	16.3	10	65	-0.075	71.0	40.0	94.1	43
29	Dan Carpenter	BUF	14.7	7	70	-0.079	76.0	45.5	88.9	54
30	Mike Nugent	CIN	6.0	3	58	-0.124	79.3	50.0	79.3	47

Low-volume kickers (4)

Fewer than 20 FG attempts. Grades still computed on the same 0-100 scale but treat them as noisy (rookies, mid-season callups, kickers in heavy committees).

						FORMULA	CONTEXT
Rank
1	Josh Brown	NYG	69.5	80	21	+0.042	91.7	80.0	100.0	48
2	Robbie Gould	NYG	43.5	37	33	-0.019	100.0	100.0	87.0	47
3	Kai Forbath	MIN	41.8	37	29	-0.023	100.0	100.0	78.6	51
4	Blair Walsh	MIN	10.4	3	35	-0.111	75.0	71.4	78.9	50