NFL Player Grades
Player Grades
Team Grades
Methodology
Research
Indianapolis Colts — 2023
← Back to leaderboard
Indianapolis Colts
AFC South · 102 players
Buffalo Bills
Miami Dolphins
New England Patriots
New York Jets
Baltimore Ravens
Cincinnati Bengals
Cleveland Browns
Pittsburgh Steelers
Houston Texans
Indianapolis Colts
Jacksonville Jaguars
Tennessee Titans
Denver Broncos
Kansas City Chiefs
Las Vegas Raiders
Los Angeles Chargers
Dallas Cowboys
New York Giants
Philadelphia Eagles
Washington Commanders
Chicago Bears
Detroit Lions
Green Bay Packers
Minnesota Vikings
Atlanta Falcons
Carolina Panthers
New Orleans Saints
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Arizona Cardinals
Los Angeles Rams
San Francisco 49ers
Seattle Seahawks
2025
2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
2025
2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
Team grade · 2023
48.4
Overall
47 pct
43.5
Offense
44
58.2
Defense
66
31.7
S. Teams
25
Position breakdown
Offense
QB
37
OL
52
Starting lineup
4-2-5 Nickel
FS
Rodney Thomas
›
30.0
SS
Nick Cross
›
Full roster
all
offense
defense
Special teams
#
Player
▼
Pos
▼
▼
GP / GS
▼
Snaps
▼
Grade
Pct
1
DeForest Buckner
›
iDL
17
/ 16
861
80.0
95
2
Julian Blackmon
›
S
15
/ 14
1,110
79.0
99
3
Nick Cross
›
low volume
S
17
/ 15
593
73.1
97
4
Jonathan Taylor
›
RB
10
/ 8
386
65.8
84
5
E.J. Speed
›
LB
16
/ 10
977
63.7
93
6
Dayo Odeyingbo
›
EDGE
17
/ 11
728
62.1
71
7
Zack Moss
›
RB
14
/ 8
531
60.1
70
8
Michael Pittman
›
WR
16
/ 15
994
57.8
66
9
Josh Downs
›
WR
17
/ 15
828
57.6
65
10
Samson Ebukam
›
EDGE
17
/ 17
702
55.2
63
11
Jaylon Jones
›
CB
17
/ 13
893
53.1
55
12
Trey Sermon
›
low volume
RB
14
/ 0
126
52.1
52
13
Will Mallory
›
low volume
TE
12
/ 0
159
50.9
54
14
Kwity Paye
›
EDGE
16
/ 16
723
49.7
50
15
Tyquan Lewis
›
EDGE
17
/ 2
485
49.4
49
16
Julius Brents
›
CB
9
/ 8
548
46.7
46
17
Mo Alie-Cox
›
low volume
TE
17
/ 5
557
43.0
34
18
Andrew Ogletree
›
low volume
TE
12
/ 4
455
42.7
31
19
Zaire Franklin
›
LB
16
/ 16
1,187
41.4
21
20
Matt Gay
›
K
17
/ 2
172
41.4
29
21
Taven Bryan
›
low volume
iDL
17
/ 0
505
40.0
38
22
Kylen Granson
›
TE
15
/ 8
655
39.7
29
23
Gardner Minshew
›
QB
17
/ 15
972
37.9
37
24
Grover Stewart
›
iDL
11
/ 10
565
36.4
32
25
Eric Johnson
›
low volume
iDL
14
/ 0
329
35.8
30
26
Alec Pierce
›
WR
17
/ 17
1,093
35.5
25
27
Anthony Richardson
›
low volume
QB
4
/ 2
173
33.8
26
28
Kenny Moore II
›
CB
16
/ 16
1,197
33.2
21
29
Rigoberto Sanchez
›
P
17
/ 0
151
32.0
19
30
Darrell Baker Jr.
›
CB
14
/ 8
635
31.9
19
31
Rodney Thomas
›
S
17
/ 15
1,139
30.0
12
32
Will Fries
›
OL
17
/ 17
1,204
—
—
33
Quenton Nelson
›
OL
17
/ 17
1,174
—
—
34
Bernhard Raimann
›
OL
15
/ 15
1,084
—
—
35
Ryan Kelly
›
OL
14
/ 14
882
—
—
36
Blake Freeland
›
OL
16
/ 10
729
—
—
37
Braden Smith
›
OL
10
/ 9
589
—
—
38
Segun Olubi
›
LB
15
/ 14
448
—
—
39
Grant Stuard
›
LB
17
/ 17
381
—
—
40
Wesley French
›
OL
17
/ 3
335
—
—
41
Dallis Flowers
›
CB
4
/ 4
332
—
—
42
Trevor Denbow
›
S
17
/ 17
331
—
—
43
Jacob Martin
›
EDGE
17
/ 1
318
—
—
44
Tony Brown
›
CB
12
/ 10
308
—
—
45
Ronnie Harrison
›
LB
7
/ 3
298
—
—
46
Ameer Speed
›
S
13
/ 10
239
—
—
47
Isaiah McKenzie
›
WR
13
/ 0
226
—
—
48
Adetomiwa Adebawore
›
iDL
10
/ 0
206
—
—
49
D.J. Montgomery
›
WR
7
/ 2
177
—
—
50
Cameron McGrone
›
LB
12
/ 3
159
—
—
51
Luke Rhodes
›
LS
17
/ 0
152
—
—
52
Josh Sills
›
OL
17
/ 0
116
—
—
53
Chris Lammons
›
CB
4
/ 3
116
—
—
54
Juwann Winfree
›
WR
8
/ 2
96
—
—
55
Tyler Goodson
›
RB
6
/ 0
52
—
—
56
Amari Rodgers
›
WR
3
/ 1
48
—
—
57
Isaiah Land
›
EDGE
7
/ 0
45
—
—
58
Ethan Fernea
›
WR
3
/ 0
29
—
—
59
Liam Anderson
›
LB
1
/ 0
8
—
—
60
Ike Boettger
›
OL
2
/ 0
8
—
—
61
Evan Hull
›
RB
1
/ 0
8
—
—
62
Jack Anderson
›
OL
1
/ 0
6
—
—
63
Arlington Hambright
›
OL
2
/ 0
6
—
—
64
Sam Ehlinger
›
QB
1
/ 0
3
—
—
65
Kevin Toliver
›
CB
0
/ 0
—
—
—
66
Vyncint Smith
›
WR
0
/ 0
—
—
—
67
James Washington
›
WR
0
/ 0
—
—
—
68
Genard Avery
›
EDGE
0
/ 0
—
—
—
69
Malik Turner
›
WR
0
/ 0
—
—
—
70
Ashton Dulin
›
WR
0
/ 0
—
—
—
71
Henry Black
›
S
0
/ 0
—
—
—
72
Danny Pinter
›
OL
0
/ 0
—
—
—
73
Jason Huntley
›
RB
0
/ 0
—
—
—
74
Tyrie Cleveland
›
WR
0
/ 0
—
—
—
75
Nick Eubanks
›
TE
0
/ 0
—
—
—
76
Kellen Mond
›
QB
0
/ 0
—
—
—
77
Darren Hall
›
CB
0
/ 0
—
—
—
78
Zach McCloud
›
EDGE
0
/ 0
—
—
—
79
Lewis Kidd
›
OL
0
/ 0
—
—
—
80
Isaac Taylor-Stuart
›
CB
0
/ 0
—
—
—
81
Jelani Woods
›
TE
0
/ 0
—
—
—
82
Marcel Dabo
›
S
0
/ 0
—
—
—
83
Daniel Scott
›
S
0
/ 0
—
—
—
84
Titus Leo
›
EDGE
0
/ 0
—
—
—
85
Jake Witt
›
OL
0
/ 0
—
—
—
86
Emil Ekiyor
›
OL
0
/ 0
—
—
—
87
Caleb Sampson
›
iDL
0
/ 0
—
—
—
88
Zavier Scott
›
RB
0
/ 0
—
—
—
89
Tyler Adams
›
WR
0
/ 0
—
—
—
90
Kody Case
›
WR
0
/ 0
—
—
—
91
Matthew Vanderslice
›
OL
0
/ 0
—
—
—
92
Tyreque Jones
›
S
0
/ 0
—
—
—
93
Jordan Murray
›
TE
0
/ 0
—
—
—
94
Austin Ajiake
›
LB
0
/ 0
—
—
—
95
Jared Veldheer
›
OL
0
/ 0
—
—
—
96
Eric Tomlinson
›
TE
0
/ 0
—
—
—
97
Breshad Perriman
›
WR
0
/ 0
—
—
—
98
Jaydon Mickens
›
WR
0
/ 0
—
—
—
99
Ricky Seals-Jones
›
TE
0
/ 0
—
—
—
100
Brandon Wilson
›
S
0
/ 0
—
—
—
101
Derek Rivers
›
EDGE
0
/ 0
—
—
—
102
Al-Quadin Muhammad
›
EDGE
0
/ 0
—
—
—
WR
49
RB
61
TE
43
Defense
EDGE
54
CB
41
LB
50
S
57
iDL
56
Special teams
K
41
P
32
Overall grade trend
Snap-weighted aggregate of the player grades on this team, by position, weighted into Offense / Defense / Special-teams (see
methodology
).
73.1
SLOT CB
Kenny Moore II
›
33.2
LB
E.J. Speed
›
63.7
LB
Zaire Franklin
›
41.4
LCB
Jaylon Jones
›
53.1
EDGE
Kwity Paye
›
49.7
iDL
DeForest Buckner
›
80.0
iDL
Grover Stewart
›
36.4
EDGE
Tyquan Lewis
›
49.4
RCB
Ameer Speed
›
—
WR1
Josh Downs
›
57.6
OL
52.2
LT
Raimann
LG
Nelson
C
Kelly
RG
Fries
RT
Smith
TE
Mo Alie-Cox
›
43.0
WR2
D.J. Montgomery
›
—
QB
Gardner Minshew
›
37.9
RB
Jonathan Taylor
›
65.8
Special teams
K
Matt Gay
›
41.4
P
Rigoberto Sanchez
›
32.0
Offense
QB
Gardner Minshew
›
37.9
RB
Jonathan Taylor
›
65.8
WR1
Josh Downs
›
57.6
WR2
D.J. Montgomery
›
—
TE
Mo Alie-Cox
›
43.0
Offensive line
Team grade
52.2
LT
Raimann
LG
Nelson
C
Kelly
RG
Fries
RT
Smith
Defense
EDGE
Kwity Paye
›
49.7
iDL
DeForest Buckner
›
80.0
iDL
Grover Stewart
›
36.4
EDGE
Tyquan Lewis
›
49.4
LB
Special teams
K
Matt Gay
›
41.4
P
Rigoberto Sanchez
›
32.0
E.J. Speed
›
63.7
LB
Zaire Franklin
›
41.4
LCB
Jaylon Jones
›
53.1
SLOT CB
Kenny Moore II
›
33.2
RCB
Ameer Speed
›
—
FS
Rodney Thomas
›
30.0
SS
Nick Cross
›
73.1